Back to Amazon.com
customer reviews
1,771
3.8 out of 5 stars

WD MyCloud Network Attached Storage

$109.99
$189.99 42% off Reference Price
Capacity: 3TB
Condition: Factory Reconditioned
Sold out Back to product details

Top positive review
3 people found this helpful
Exceeded expectations
By Paul on Reviewed in the United States on May 4, 2016
I’m a busy IT executive that wanted something simple for the entire household to use without having to spend countless hours on building and maintaining my own custom NAS. A few basic requirements outside of standard LAN CIFS access were automatic iPhone backups to complement existing iCloud storage, the ability to enforce basic Read, Read/Write, and Deny access ACLs, and transparent proxy capabilities for true “Cloud Access” while away from home. To sum it up, I wanted the family to have the ability to backup their iPhones and have a simple and securable Internet accessible NAS to use. The device was incredibly easy to configure, had a sleek look, and both random and sequential IO performance tests were more than acceptable for a pair of low performance SATA spindles with a single Gigabit Ethernet connection. I read mixed performance reviews about this and competing NAS devices, but many of those people just don’t understand the basics of networking and storage (why should they, right?) – IOPS, switching speed/capabilities, parity selection, workload types, cache, and countless other variables need to be considered for setting performance expectations. WD Performance summary – exceeded expectations for a home user NAS consisting of a mere 2 traditional hard drives and attached to consumer grade networking components. If you can have more than one intensive read/write operation going at the same time and sustain 50+MBps on sequential Read and Write operations than you’re doing pretty darn good with this type of equipment. It’s meant for a handful of people to use at the same time with maybe one or two of those users transferring anything significant in size. WD User Experience Summary - the WD solution has a few quirks, but their development team clearly understood what had to be done for an acceptable user experience. They spent the time and money creating a real transparent bridge between their “mycloud.com” data center presence to the MyCloud NAS product. Shares can be secured and easily accessed from the outside. This is done using some form of single-sign on solution. Even better, they have a real commitment to continue improving the product. That can’t be said for the Seagate solution. In plain English, you create a “mycloud.com” user account, link that account with an account on the NAS, and a trusted connection between the two accounts is created. Once done, you can login using a web browser or the mobile device app with your @mycloud.com account and it transparently and securely bridges a connection to only the shares that account has permission to access. Seagate Personal Cloud Comparison: Access control and the general user experience on the Seagate solution was unacceptable. Basic permissions could be applied to shares when wanting to view the data on the local network, but only non-secure data could be accessed from the iPhone application. I spent about 30 minutes searching the net to see if it was something that I was missing, but no, it wasn’t. Buried in the manual, not to be confused with conflicting marketing propaganda, it was clearly identified that anything accessed from the mobile app had to be in the “public” synonymous with “everyone” folder. STX fell short on the intelligence portion of this “personal cloud” product. It’s very clear they didn’t spend enough development dollars or have the right talent building a real “proxy service” between the personal cloud devices and their data centers. The solution is kludged together and appears to have been managed by product managers that didn’t understand their target consumer. In plain English, they should have built software to securely and transparently link, or bridge, devices connecting from outside of the home network (proxy). I immediately packed up the device, returned it, then purchased a Western Digital My Cloud Mirror gen 2. Final thoughts: 1. A+ to Western Digital and the MyCloud Gen 2 2. D- to the Seagate Personal Cloud
Top critical review
10 people found this helpful
WD My Cloud any version: AVOID – JUNK – WILL LET YOU DOWN
By 4mark2009 on Reviewed in the United States on March 30, 2015
WDMyCloud any version: AVOID – JUNK – WILL LET YOU DOWN WHEN YOU NEED IT. After 5 weeks of trying to live with this poor cheap NAS choice. I have given up on the Western Digital WDMyCloud. But first, let’s qualify the reviewer: (I can’t spell)… However, I am 51 with 25+ year experienced “IT” professional. My resume includes: Cisco advanced services, IBM Risc, SCO/BSD Unix, Adaptec/Areca/many other RAID’s, Computer/Server builder, and Microsoft Technician support for every flavor Microsoft (1988, 3.1) to (2014, hate 8, hope 10 is better) . I am now semi-retired. I have no ties to any manufacture and I have nothing to sell you. First, let’s talk about WD tech support. PLAINLY, you can’t get to 2nd tear support. I experienced 5 days trying as they must call you on an open support ticket #system. But, this is a game playing phone tag. They ringing your phone twice then hang up when you answer, they send you an email “sorry we missed you”. After 5 days of my effort re-trying contact, WD can not prove to me they even have a level 2 tech support. So, let’s talk about level 1, support: They must be sweatshop workers. They are trained and strictly tied to an SOP menu. First, they force you to: register answering 38 personal question wasting 16 minutes of your time (NOTE: Clock is ticking after registration, FREE SUPPORT End’s 30 DAYS AFTER REGISTRATION). Next, they connect you to Mr. /Ms Clueless who will lecture you about Browser versions, JAVA, Device ups/downs. They usually ask for “REMOTE ACCESS YOUR SYSTEM so they can snoop around in your computer rather than support the troubled WD NAS device. WD tear 1 support absolutely refused to connect to my NAS using their own software and WD-go Website. WD Support will NOT login using a login name and password you setup so they can test and see what you are experiencing using their crap hardware and software. After I requested elevated support, I even trapped two WD support technician in bare faced lie(s). Tech Support lies are serious issue: So, let me elaborate: By this time I had requested a 3rd higher level technician with authorization to use and login to the WD remote access website, www.wd2go.com/login.do. The new phone tech asked the same SOP AGAIN, Then, he put me on hold saying he would try to login with my test login and remote password. 8 minutes on hold. When he returned, he said I have a poorly configured MyCloud because his attempt gave a device error. I asked him why he never requested the SECOND REQUIRED PASSWORD. Wow, did he fall over his Tung stumbling for excuses to cover the fact that he never seen a prompt for a device password because he never tried and does not even know how the WD remote Web Site works. I exposed the next WD Phone (supervisor) in the same lie. Only this time he said he got in, the JAVA ran se could see but, he could not open my share points (“the actual problem”). So, I asked him to read me the “NAME” of my shares? He could not tell me what he was seeing as my shares because even this so called “supervisor” had never actually tried to login to tested anything. PROOF OF WD TECH & SUPERVISOR LIES: Router log setup to log access to port 8080 and 8443 confirm no attempt was ever made to test access by any WD Technician. The log shows every access from WAN users to the WDMycoud, confirmed. Note to all: MUST HAVE A GOOD UPS TO USE ANY NAS. WDMycloud 3Tb: It is extremely unstable, requires frequent power cycling (unplug). It hangs 50% of the time if you click REBOOT from the utilities menu. Network speed is dog slow on a 100/1000, true 1G network with no other traffic. The best I could get was 52 from my fastest server and 44 from a WIFI Laptop. Very bad issue: If you upload files to fast, the WD content scan will hang and cause the WD Mycloud to go nuts requiring a full power cycle. I had to group my uploads into sets of 3 files at a time pause 1 full minute before the next 3 files. File size from 500Kb to 1,800Kb, it did not matter. Try uploading 900 videos of 1 gig each like I just described and you will know the agony this NAS device has caused me. The 11TH DAY: After uploading 1.4 gig as above, it worked for 3 users with share access accounts to the content share. But, on the 11TH DAY: The share content would not open on the www.wd2go web site. It would not let me mount/map the drive anymore, (local or remote), “net use” stopped working. Only access that worked was by device generated code on a WD application that only lets you view/hear your shared content. (No Firmware changed, auto update disabled, check firmware showed, “up to date” on March 18th and today. March 29, 2015. No changes were made, no content added. It just stopped working. QUICK, FULL. and, FACTORY RESTORE: Tried them all, total rebuild 2 times. It worked. Yes, it worked for 3 days locally but still no access using www.wd2go remote drive map access. Would I use WD Mycloud to backup anything? OH MY GOD NO! If you could keep the MyCloud functioning (you cant), a full computer hard drive restore of say 250gig would require 5 hours or more at the above said extremely slow network speed considering it’s a NAS. For comparison: I have a cheap Buffalo NAS from 2009 that transfers files 30% faster 80Mbs. And also, my own design NAS gives its users 230Mbs locally over a congested 1000 Ethernet. The WD Mycloud sucks eggs on every level. I want my money back and the chance to chew out every Western Digital Corporate Executive Officer including: Mr. Stephen D. Milligan, President and Chief Executive Officer. Western Digital, 3355 Michelson Drive, Suite 100, Irvine, California 92612. My name is service ticket #032515-9744051, Mark… ------------------------ Update 4/2 15: After my post here on Amazon I received a nice call from WD, James who put me in contact with Tim, a good tech. We reinstalled firmware, ran a system check, downloaded a 4meg system check log and, then I was offered my money back. Tech talking to Tech the process was oven in 30 minutes on phone. So, my purchase receipt was emailed and I’m looking for a check in the mail. WD has 3 product lines dependent on the same OS and remote access system. They are all broken in the current firmware and WD-GO remote web site. WD Corporate office can not be contacted by phone or email. I tried hard to contact them because this is a 3 product-line design flaw. But, WD Corporate office does NOT want public contact unless in written US Mail. I had $40,000.00 in WD stock until 10:05AM today. WD Corporate Office is going to freak when more people learn how badly the cloud products are broken. WD stock is going to suffer the customer outrage. Yet, I give my thanks to James and Tim for assistance and Honesty. Update 4/14/2015: Refund check recived. Thank you James and Tim. People, currently the WD Mycoud is THE WORST NAS on the market. Unfortanetly the true reviews showing how bad it is are being burried under piles of "PAID" reviewers. Not sure how much Amazon can do about that problem. Just know that WD Support is cluless no matter what your question, they cant answer. WD Mycloud ALL PRODUCTLINES: ARE extremely unstable, requires frequent power cycling (unplug). They hangs 50% of the time if you click REBOOT from the utilities menu. Network speed is dog slow on a 100/1000, true 1G network with no other traffic. The best I could get was 52 from my fastest server and 44 from a WIFI Laptop. Very bad issue: If you upload files to fast, the WD content scan will hang and cause the WD Mycloud to go nuts requiring a full power cycle. I had to group my uploads into sets of 3 files at a time pause 1 full minute before the next 3 files. File size from 500Kb to 1,800Kb, it did not matter. Try uploading 900 videos of 1 gig each like I just described and you will know the agony this NAS device has caused me. AVOID ALL WD CLOUD JUNK!

Sort by:
Filter by:
By -
Verified Amazon Purchase
Vine Customer Review of Free Product
Sorry, no reviews match your current selections.
Try clearing or changing some filters.Show all reviews
Show more reviews


people found this helpful
By -
Verified Amazon Purchase
Vine Customer Review of Free Product